We’re continuing our series of joint posts with Christian Writers Downunder. Today, author and missionary Christine Dillon is discussing Women’s Fiction (which, despite the name, isn’t just for women).
Introducing Women’s Fiction
According to Wikipedia, Women’s Fiction includes layered stories about one or several characters, often multi-generational that tackles an adult character’s struggle with world issues resulting in emotional growth. It may include elements of mystery, fantasy, romance or other subgenres, but is not driven by these elements.
The Women’s Fiction Writers Association says:
the driving force of women’s fiction is the protagonist’s journey toward a more fulfilled self.
When I started writing fiction I hadn’t yet heard of women’s fiction. I called my books ‘contemporary inspirational’ or ‘issues-based Christian fiction’ (a label I invented).
At the same time I was reading a lot of Christian fiction and getting frustrated at the huge number of romance stories out there which just weren’t my thing (with a few exceptions). I started asking around, saying, “You know, books like Francine Rivers writes, tackling an issue like abortion or divorce. Issues that people face in their daily lives.”
“Oh, you’re looking for women’s fiction,” I was told.
My thoughts on Women’s Fiction
My initial response was lukewarm to having my books labelled ‘women’s’ fiction because I hoped men would read them too. There doesn’t appear to be an equivalent genre for men.
When people ask me about my books I still use my own definition of ‘contemporary Australian Christian fiction that tackles issues that Christian’s face in their daily lives.’
Women’s Fiction tends to be contemporary but some historical stories have women’s fiction elements. Think Redeeming Love by Francine Rivers, or biblical fiction—Pearl in the Sand or Land of Silence by Tessa Afshar.
Elements Found in Women’s Fiction
- A crisis issue like abortion, divorce, spouse having an affair, accident, or unemployment, that triggers emotion and eventually life change.
- A focus on the emotional and thought-life of the character. It is a spiritual (if it is Christian fiction) and emotional journey for the lead character(s).
- Nil or minimal romance. If there is romance, it is not the focus of the story. After all, it is pretty hard to avoid any romance if you’re writing about real people.
- Women’s fiction doesn’t need a ‘happily ever after’ ending, which is something romance readers seem to expect.
- Character-driven stories rather than action driven.
- The main characters are often women, but in my opinion don’t have to be. Otherwise my third and fourth books in my ‘Grace’ series are not going to be the same genre as the others.
- Readers can often say, ‘I’ve experienced that’ or ‘I wonder what I would do in that situation?’ These stories often prompt discussion.
- The book often ends with a reflection from the main character about what they’ve experienced and how their life will change.
Women’s (Christian) Fiction I’ve enjoyed:
- Deborah Raney – she specialises in putting people in situations
- Ginny Yttrup – especially Words
- Brenda S Anderson
- Catherine West
- Francine Rivers – I especially like And the Shofar Blew
- Ann Tatlock
Here’s a question for men:
Have you read books that are labelled ‘women’s fiction’ – what did you think? What did you like or not like?
P.S. Christine has been delighted that many men love her books and she even has younger teen boys who can’t wait for the next.
Thank you Christine. I always wondered how limiting it could be to label books “Women’s Fiction”. It’s good to know that you have men reading your books too!
I’ve read books by Francine Rivers and Catherine West (and Christine Dillon, of course!) that I’ve enjoyed. It’s good to see the breadth and depths Women’s Fiction allows issues to be discussed.
I have read some women’s fiction and have to say one really disappointed me because it wasn’t labeled as Women’s Fiction but under inspirational fiction (or romance). While it was a good book I was disappointed because it was labelled wrong.
I have read a few good Women’s Fiction Verina Denman ‘s Looking Glass Lies was a good Read.
Hi Christine, I’ve read many women’s fiction books that answer the question: What happens after the initial romance story ends. Romance is the journey to the big relationship commitment, and women’s fiction looks at what happens afterwards. I don’t expect a happy ending in women’s fiction/contemporary fiction, but I do look for a satisfying ending. I also keep a box of tissues handy, as many women’s fiction books are tearjerkers. I’ve always enjoyed Debbie Macomber’s books, but I’m not a Nicholas Sparks fan.